| Class of 2012 New Jersey Final State Rankings | |||||
| Rank | Name | Pos | City (State) High School | Ht/Wt | Verbal |
| 1 | Darius Hamilton | DE | Ramsey (N.J.) Don Bosco Prep | 6-3/245 | |
| 2 | Elijah Shumate | S | Ramsey (N.J.) Don Bosco Prep | 6-1/205 | Notre Dame |
| 3 | Leonte Carroo | WR | Ramsey (N.J.) Don Bosco Prep | 6-1/200 | Rutgers |
| 4 | Devin Fuller | QB | Old Tappan (N.J.) No. Valley Regional | 6-0/185 | |
| 5 | D.J. Singleton | S | Jersey City (N.J.) St. Peter's Prep | 6-3/195 | Wisconsin |
| 6 | Yuri Wright | CB | Ramsey (N.J.) Don Bosco Prep | 6-2/180 | |
| 7 | Quanzell Lambert | MLB | Erial (N.J.) Timber Creek | 6-2/245 | Rutgers |
| 8 | Kye Morgan | RB | Somerset (N.J.) Franklin | 5-11/180 | Virginia |
| 9 | Ryan Brodie | OT | Long Branch (N.J.) | 6-5/265 | Rutgers |
| 10 | Austin Johnson | OG | Richland (N.J.) St. Augustine | 6-4/275 | Penn State |
| 11 | Brandon Napoleon | CB | Jersey City (N.J.) St. Peter's Prep | 6-0/175 | West Virginia |
| 12 | Jamil Pollard | DT | Westville (N.J.) West Deptford | 6-4/280 | Penn State |
| 13 | Delon Stephenson | WR | Parlin (N.J.) Sayreville | 5-11/175 | Rutgers |
| 14 | Kaiwan Lewis | MLB | Hammonton (N.J.) St. joseph's | 6-2/235 | South Carolina |
| 15 | Davon Jacobs | S | Wayne (N.J.) De Paul Catholic | 6-2/185 | Rutgers |
| 16 | Julian Pinnix-Odrick | DT | Montclair (N.J.) | 6-5/265 | Rutgers |
| 17 | Christian Brown | DT | Bridgeton (N.J.) | 6-2/290 | West Virginia |
| 18 | Mike Strizak | MLB | Ramsey (N.J.) Don Bosco Prep | 6-3/225 | Boston College |
| 19 | Jim Cashman | OT | Haddonfield (N.J.) Memorial | 6-7/275 | Boston College |
| 20 | Mike Giacone | TE | Jersey City (N.J.) St. Peter's Prep | 6-5/230 | Rutgers |
| 21 | Jevon Tyree | CB | Monmouth (N.J.) South Brunswick | 5-11/180 | |
| 22 | John Ferranto | OT | Burlington (N.J.) Township | 6-5/250 | North Carolina |
| 23 | Ryan Morris | TE | Barnegat (N.J.) | 6-6/248 | Purdue |
| 24 | Dan Crimmins | TE | Demarest (N.J.) Northern Valley Reg. | 6-5/225 | Boston College |
| 25 | Vin Ascolese | OLB | North Bergen (N.J.) | 6-2/215 | |
| 26 | Stephaun Marshall | S | Montclair (N.J.) | 6-2/192 | Temple |
| 27 | Ruhann Peele | WR | Linden (N.J.) | 6-1/185 | Rutgers |
| 28 | Dan Mastromatteo | OLB | Absecon (N.J.) Holy Spirit | 6-2/215 | North Carolina |
| 29 | Sean Maguire | QB | West Orange (N.J.) Seton Hall Prep | 6-3/195 | Florida State |
| 30 | Max Valles | WR | Hammonton (N.J.) St. Joseph's | 6-4/210 | Virginia |
| 31 | Carlton Agudosi | WR | Somerset (N.J.) Franklin | 6-6/205 | Rutgers |
| 32 | Shahbaz Ahmed | DE | Haddonfield (N.J.) Paul VI | 6-3/225 | Temple |
| 33 | Wendy Laurent | C | Princeton (N.J.) | 6-4/285 | Penn State |
| 34 | Marcus Coleman | DT | Cherry Hill (N.J.) Camden Catholic | 6-2/280 | Syracuse |
| 35 | Ray Korang | OT | Mount Holly (N.J.) Rancocas Valley | 6-8/285 | Temple |