| Class of 2012 New York Final State Rankings |
| Rank | Name | Pos |
City (State) High School | Ht/Wt | Verbal |
| 1 | Jarron Jones | OT | Rochester (N.Y.) Aquinas Institute | 6-5/290 | Notre Dame |
| 2 | Akeel Lynch | RB | Athol Springs (N.Y.) St. Francis | 6-1/205 | Penn State |
| 3 | Chad Kelly | QB | Buffalo (N.Y.) St. Joseph's Collegiate | 6-3/205 | Clemson |
| 4 | Mikal Myers | DT | Newburgh (N.Y.) Newburgh Free | 6-0/310 | Connecticut |
| 5 | Sean Karl | OT | Eastport (N.Y.) South Manor | 6-6/285 | Virginia |
| 6 | Jahmahl Pardner | S | Rochester (Ny.) Aquinas Institute | 6-0/170 | Pittsburgh |
| 7 | DeVante McFarlane | RB | Dix Hills (N.Y.) Half Hollow Hills | 6-1/195 | Syracuse |
| 8 | Corey Madlock | DT | Buffalo (N.Y.) Canisius | 6-4/280 | Buffalo |
| 9 | Wayne Morgan | S | Brooklyn (N.Y.) Erasmus Hall | 5-11/190 | |
| 10 | Alvin Cornelius | WR | Staten Island (N.Y.) Tottenville | 6-3/190 | Syracuse |
| 11 | A.J. Wolf | DE | Tarrytown (N.Y.) Hackley | 6-4/245 | Duke |
| 12 | Omari Palmer | OG | Middle Island (N.Y.) Longwood | 6-3/295 | Syracuse |
| 13 | Ben Barrett | OG | Syracuse (N.Y.) Christian Brothers Acad. | 6-4.5/255 | Syracuse |
| 14 | Miles Bartholomew | OG | Athol Springs (N.Y.) St. Francis | 6-4/270 | |
| 15 | Stacey Bedell | RB | Mastic Beach (N.Y.) William Floyd | 5-10/175 | Villanova |
| 16 | Justin Combs | CB | New Rochelle (N.Y.) Iona Prep | 5-9/175 | UCLA |
| 17 | Poncho Barnwell | DE | Rochester (N.Y.) East | 6-4/220 | Syracuse |
| 18 | Jordan Johnson | CB | Amherst (N.Y.) Sweet Home | 6-1/190 | Buffalo |
| 19 | Jaden Cotton | OT | Depew (N.Y.) | 6-5/291 | Buffalo |
| 20 | Marcus McGill | WR | Rochester (N.Y.) Gates-Chili | 6-1/195 | Buffalo |
